By Paul Evans
The Acting Chief Executive of Welsh Rugby Union (WRU), Nigel Walker, has warned that the allegations of misogyny, sexism, racism, and homophobia that have come to light could put the future of rugby in Wales at risk.
The allegations of a “toxic culture” within the WRU were revealed in a recent TV documentary, which led to the resignation of the Chief Executive Steve Phillips on January 29th.
To address these allegations, an independent taskforce is being set up, with the advice of Sport Wales, a government-funded body, on the composition and scope of the panel.
WRU chair Ieuan Evans said it was his responsibility to “go out to clubs and drive change” at an extraordinary general meeting proposed for March, and Walker admits Welsh rugby is in a perilous position after member clubs voted down governance reform in October.
Asked how clubs could be persuaded to support change, Walker said at a press conference in Cardiff: “You come up for a compelling argument for change because where we are now is not sustainable.
“If we are not prepared to change, the future of Welsh rugby and the Welsh Rugby Union is in danger. I can’t put it any more bluntly than that.
“We’ve accepted we need change and we want to get to that change programme as quickly as possible.”
A week that won’t be forgotten for Welsh rugby. Thanks to acting CEO Nigel Walker for joining us on @BBCScrumV last night. You can catch the full episode here https://t.co/5NzyA0euW2 pic.twitter.com/NPqRl0aASH
— Lauren Jenkins (@laurenemmaj) January 30, 2023
A number of former WRU employees took part in an investigation by BBC Wales with accusations about their time at the organisation.
Charlotte Wathan, general manager of women’s rugby until her resignation last February, spoke of how a male colleague said in front of others in an office that he wanted to “rape” her, while another unnamed contributor said she was left contemplating suicide by her experiences of bullying and sexism at work.
Former Olympic hurdler and Wales wing Walker, who described the allegations raised in the documentary as “harrowing and despicable”, said the rape claim had been investigated by a leading law firm.
He said: “They came to a view they couldn’t substantiate the claim and that investigation, if required by the taskforce, will be turned over to them so they can look at it and they can say it needs to be investigated again.
“If this person needs to be interviewed or that person needs to be interviewed, we will comply with it. We’re opening up our shop, no question is off the table, they can have access to everything.”
Walker wants a rapid conclusion into the investigation of the WRU – “I would hope that it would be weeks” – and a meeting was due to be held on 30th January to set its terms of reference.
“You can have it as wide as possible and it’s going to take quite a bit of time, or we can have a more defined terms of reference highlighting specific areas where perhaps the taskforce will meet and come to a conclusion more quickly,” said Walker, who was appointed WRU performance director in July 2021.
The Welsh Rugby Union have not been open and transparent with the Welsh public.
I have co-signed a letter asking the chair of the @SeneddCultureIR Committee to investigate the allegations of bullying, sexism and sexual harassment within the WRU. pic.twitter.com/mBlH1tpjTp
— Tonia Antoniazzi MP 🌈 🇺🇦 (@ToniaAntoniazzi) January 25, 2023
“That’s the balance we’ve got to strike. We don’t want to be sitting here in three, four, five months time without it having been reported because the terms of reference are so wide.
“We want to get those recommendations as quickly as possible and be fit for purpose. We need to undertake that we will implement the changes required.
“The acid test is what we do with the organisation and what people think about it. It’s about restoring credibility and it will be up to people outside the organisation to tell us when they think we’ve restored credibility.”
Amanda Blanc, who chaired Welsh rugby’s professional board between 2019 and 2021, warned the WRU it had a problem before the recent claims emerged.
Blanc, now chief executive of insurance company Aviva, told the WRU it had “deep-rooted” culture and behavioural problems, but Evans insisted Phillips had a part to play in the future of Welsh rugby at a press conference on 25th January.
Asked if those comments had damaged his own credibility, Evans, who has called for an independent WRU chair and is due to be questioned in the Senedd, the Welsh Parliament, on 2nd February over the allegations, said: “In my heart, I’m very loyal. I like to think I have integrity.
“It’s up to others to judge whether I have or not. Steve Phillips had made changes. But when he decided he would like to step down, we accepted that resignation.
Has there ever been a more scathing letter written to a sport in Welsh history?
Let me know what you think 👇🏼🖊️
“We will not stop campaigning until change is actioned, until the current CEO and the WRU board is either sacked or resign to safeguard the future of Welsh rugby.” https://t.co/mSxfKB0bKa
— Beth Fisher (@BethFisherSport) January 26, 2023
“We feel now is an opportunity to move forward. We need greater diversity and a greater skill set on our board to challenge and support our executive.”
Principality Building Society, sponsors of Wales’ national stadium in Cardiff and supporters of the Welsh grassroots game, issued a statement on 30th January welcoming the action over the past week and vowing to continue to hold the WRU board to account.
It read: ‘Over the past week we’ve made our expectations clear to the board of the WRU on what meaningful and decisive action we want to see them take.
‘We welcome the new independent taskforce to investigate culture and behaviours, and the constructive involvement of Sport Wales in leading the taskforce, along with the Senedd inquiry.
‘We strongly believe WRU governance changes are crucial to drive forward a much needed and demonstrable improvement in culture.
‘We acknowledge Nigel Walker’s comments that he will work tirelessly and relentlessly to ensure the WRU progresses to a better place, and we will continue to hold the WRU board to account on behalf of our customers, colleagues, and communities.’